RBSC

Collapse

Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

Google raises stakes in Patent War

Collapse
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • Google raises stakes in Patent War

    Google looks ahead as it buys up more IBM patents


    Google has gained hundreds of patents from IBM as it continues its intellectual property spending spree.

    It has acquired 187 patents and 36 applications, adding to the 1,000 it purchased from IBM last summer.

    The latest patents include a system for "using semantic networks to develop a social network".

    Google has spent billions building its technology rights portfolio, including a $12.5bn (£7.7bn) deal for Motorola Mobility.

    The California-based company has been actively bolstering its patent catalogue in the face of lawsuits from key competitors such as Apple and Microsoft.

    Among the patents acquired in this latest deal is US Patent 7,865,592 which relates specifically to social networking sites, allowing "identifying common interests between users of a communication network".

    Vicki Salmon, the chair of the litigation committee of the UK Chartered Institute of Patent Attorneys, believed this might be a nod that Google was moving from protecting existing technology and beginning to plan for the future.

    "When you start you have to play catch-up," she told the BBC.

    "When you've finished playing catch-up and you've got yourself in a stronger position, you then can begin to look forward."

    Other patents included a method for using web-based applications across additional devices, and an intriguingly titled computer phone.

    Neither Google nor IBM would comment on the deal when approached by the BBC.

    'Get real'
    Last year, Google accused its competitors of buying up what it called "bogus patents" in order to slow the development of its Android operating system.

    However, the company now appears to have succumbed to the same approach as it adds the IBM patents to a portfolio that also includes technology for driverless cars.

    Continue reading the main story

    Start Quote

    I think they've realised that they just had to get real, and understand that you can't just ignore the system”

    Piers Strickland
    Patent lawyer
    "Although you can object to a lot of cost of inconvenience by virtue of people enforcing their patents, the patent system still exists," Piers Strickland, a lawyer specialising in mobile telephone patent litigation, told the BBC

    "In order to engage with that you've either got to take licences from from people's patents, and/or aggressively increase your bartering position by buying patents.

    "I think they've realised that they just had to get real, and understand that you can't just ignore the system."

    Google's agreement to buy Motorola Mobility, announced in August last year, includes 24,500 patents, many of which could be used to defend the use of features on its Android mobile operating system.

    The purchase is currently being reviewed by competition regulators.

    'Turf war'
    Google's Motorola move came off the back of losing out on buying the 6,000-strong patent portfolio of bankrupt telecoms firm Nortel. It was outbid by a consortium of companies including Apple, Microsoft and Blackberry manufacturer Research in Motion.

    "The reality is that you've got a fairly vicious turf war going on between the different operating systems," explained Ms Salmon.

    "People want to be in there, and they want their platform established and people to be using them."

    Google is just one of many technology companies involved in patent lawsuits which seek to slow down competition or strike lucrative licensing fee settlements.

    On Wednesday, US mobile operator AT&T was forced to pay Tivo - the digital video recorder specialist - $215m plus additional undisclosed monthly licensing fees.

    The fee will vary depending on AT&T meeting growth targets for digital video recording customers until 2018.

    "No matter which projections you take, they all involve AT&T paying us significantly higher revenue than $215m," Tivo chief executive Tim Rogers said.
    TIVOLI: THE DESTRUCTION OF JAMAICA'S EVIL EMPIRE

    Recognizing the victims of Jamaica's horrendous criminality and exposing the Dummies like Dippy supporting criminals by their deeds.. or their silence.

    D1 - Xposing Dummies since 2007

  • #2
    Kodak under pressure, trying to sell thier patents.

    I guess its all they have left that has any worth....
    -----------------------------------------------------------

    Kodak Preparing for Chapter 11 Filing

    By Mike Spector and Dana Mattioli | The Wall Street Journal

    Eastman Kodak Co. is preparing for a Chapter 11 bankruptcy-protection filing in the coming weeks should efforts to sell a trove of digital patents fall through, people familiar with the matter said.

    The struggling photography icon, which employs about 19,000 people, is in discussions with potential lenders for around $1 billion in so-called debtor-in possession financing that would keep it afloat during bankruptcy proceedings, the people said. A filing could occur as soon as this month or early February, one of the people said.

    A Kodak spokesman said the company "does not comment on market rumor or speculation."

    [More from WSJ.com: Famous Hoteliers Get Wake-Up Call]

    Should Kodak seek Chapter 11 protection from creditors, the company would then try to sell its portfolio of 1,100 patents through a court-supervised bankruptcy auction, the people said. Kodak would continue to pay its bills and operate normally while under bankruptcy protection, the people said.

    Kodak is still making last-ditch efforts to sell the patents, which would keep the company from filing for bankruptcy protection, one of the people said. But the 131-year-old former blue chip company has started making preparations for a Chapter 11 bankruptcy filing if those efforts don't come to fruition, the person said.

    Kodak warned in a securities filing in November it will run out of cash to fund operations unless it sells its patents or is able to borrow more money.

    On Tuesday, Kodak disclosed that the New York Stock Exchange warned the company it could be delisted unless its fortunes rebound in the next six months.

    Kodak's shares have closed under $1 for 30 consecutive trading days. They were 18% lower in midafternoon trading Wednesday at 54 cents apiece, after The Wall Street Journal reported the company was preparing a possible Chapter 11 filing.

    ‪Once a high flier, Kodak has been burning cash as it tries to transform itself from a company dependent on film sales to one built around commercial and consumer printers. The company's problems intensified in 2011, as Chief Executive Antonio Perez's strategy of using patent lawsuits and licensing deals to raise cash to fund the turnaround ran dry.

    ‪In the fall, Kodak hired restructuring advisers and drew down $160 million from a credit line, heightening concerns about its viability.

    [Also see: Are You Tipping Correctly?]

    ‪Kodak's bankruptcy preparations come after months of trying to find other ways to rework its finances, mainly by selling its patents. The company has said it is running a competitive bidding process for the patents – which it put on the block in August -- but efforts to sell the portfolio have been slowed by potential bidders' concerns that Kodak might seek bankruptcy protection.

    ‪Now, Kodak is considering using bankruptcy proceedings to run a court-supervised auction to sell the patents, much as Nortel Networks Corp. did last year, people familiar with the matter said. Nortel's patents were sold to a consortium of companies for $4.5 billion, much more than expected.

    ‪The success of that sale and the formal rules associated with a bankruptcy auction have encouraged Kodak to seriously weigh seeking Chapter 11 protection to unload the patents, the people said. The auction would be overseen by a judge, with court-approved procedures that could provide more certainty for reluctant bidders, the people said.

    ‪Such an auction would follow strict rules, requiring bidders to make open offers that others could then evaluate and attempt to top. Kodak believes a bankruptcy auction could encourage bidders to reveal how they would value the company's patents and make a sale smoother, one person said.

    ‪A bankruptcy filing could also allow Kodak to shed some pension and health-care obligations to retirees, which cost the company hundreds of millions of dollars each year.

    [More from WSJ.com: Secrets of the Operating Room]

    ‪During a two-day meeting of the company's board, management and advisers in mid-December, executives were briefed on how to fund Kodak during bankruptcy proceedings should efforts to sell its patents fall short, a person familiar with the matter said. The company told directors it needed to sell the patents or borrow more money to stave off bankruptcy, this person said.

    ‪Any bankruptcy filing would require Kodak to seek debtor-in-possession financing to keep the company operating while it ran an auction for the patents. Kodak is in discussions with large banks including J.P. Morgan Chase & Co., Citigroup Inc. and Wells Fargo & Co. for those funds, people familiar with the matter said.

    Kodak has also held discussions with bondholders about a bankruptcy financing package, the people said. Another hedge fund that doesn't hold Kodak debt, Cerberus Capital Management LP, has also held talks with Kodak on behalf of a group willing to provide the financing, the people said.
    "‎It is easier to build strong children than to repair broken men" - Frederick Douglass

    Comment


    • #3
      The once mighty continue to fall by the wayside

      New World Orda
      TIVOLI: THE DESTRUCTION OF JAMAICA'S EVIL EMPIRE

      Recognizing the victims of Jamaica's horrendous criminality and exposing the Dummies like Dippy supporting criminals by their deeds.. or their silence.

      D1 - Xposing Dummies since 2007

      Comment

      Working...
      X