RBSC

Collapse

Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

'Draconian laws' - Human-rights lobbyist outs Golding's

Collapse
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • 'Draconian laws' - Human-rights lobbyist outs Golding's

    'Draconian laws' - Human-rights lobbyist outs Golding's anti-crime plan

    GOVERNMENT INTENDS to amend the Bail Act to prevent persons charged with gun offences from obtaining bail within the first 90 days of being arrested. There is also a plan to require mandatory sentencing for specified offences.

    Prime Minister Bruce Golding is to make these announcements in Parliament on Tuesday, but he may alter his plans following an open letter from human-rights advocate Yvonne McCalla-Sobers revealing his strategies.
    Golding could not be reached for comment last night following McCalla-Sobers' release of the anti-crime initiative.

    McCalla-Sobers, convenor of Families Against State Terrorism, said the anti-crime proposals, which would last for at least three years, were draconian. She blasted the Government for the proposed initiative and urged that it pay more attention to the Road Map to a Safe and Secure Jamaica, the anti-crime plan Golding's Jamaica Labour Party (JLP) had crafted while in Opposition.

    No safer
    "I left your July 18 meeting with a sense of unease after you shared your Govern-ment's proposed crime initiatives with a group of human-rights defenders. It seemed to me that once again, my country's leadership was intent on adopting or reinstituting draconian measures that have made Jamaica no safer (and in reality far less safe) over the past 30 years," Sobers said in the letter.

    The prime minister told Parliament on July 15 that he would announce the anti-crime initiative this Tuesday. Golding has said the current crime scourge required "extraordinary measures".
    More than 900 Jamaicans have been murdered since January.
    One of the controversial proposals which Golding's Cabinet held close to its chest was amending the law to allow detentions for up to 28 days without charge once authorised by a police superintendent or higher officer.

    Golding's administration had also intended to announce in Parliament an amendment to the Terrorism Prevention Act.
    The human-rights advocate has insisted that "the proposals in this crime initiative relate more to suspension of rights than protection of rights, and more to punishment than prevention".

    McCalla-Sobers recommended to Golding that the approach to crime fighting be "more preventive than retributive, tackling causes of crime with a view to winning the confidence and cooperation of the law-abiding".
    "Jamaica's future reflects its past, having attained only one per cent annual growth over 30 years whilst neighbours have grown at five per cent." (Article)

  • #2
    OJ ... this is what people should be up in arms about. 3 months widout bail? What if its an innocent person? If its a case against a known gangster lfrom gangs like One Order, Klansman and Stone Crusher then, I'd have no problem with it.

    Mrs. Sobers made a good point ... MacMillian is MONS ... what is he waiting for to implement his own recommendations?
    "Jamaica's future reflects its past, having attained only one per cent annual growth over 30 years whilst neighbours have grown at five per cent." (Article)

    Comment


    • #3
      Everybody is asking - why not implement the very things they were bigging up before they assumed the reins of govt.? What about the other recommendations over the years? Why the new thinking now that seems more about punishment than prevention?


      BLACK LIVES MATTER

      Comment


      • #4
        I think this proposed law is also flawed. You know Lazie I am for law and order and for the broken window approach. What I dont believe in is the distractions which does not provide a solution and launches false hope. I dont think we need to expand the time held without charge for murder probes as simply one should not get bail if one is on a murder charge. Now the expansion of the bail before completing the charges may be different when it comes to state terrorisim ect but that is well doummented. I dont think Bruce need to re-invent the wheel. My simple steps would be: No bail for people on Murder charge. Bring the case to trial no longer than 6 months and have the witnesses examined and cross on video so we dont run into this mess of cant finding witnessess. Also this ID parade is archaic as who is going to go and say yes I saw this Don or his cronies and is them..

        Comment


        • #5
          I can go with you on this.

          Though I could support a 7-14 day extention for lock up with probable cause, if the judge allows it after say 3 days.

          Comment


          • #6
            fair enough..

            Comment


            • #7
              One characteristic of good leadership is RESOLUTENESS.

              Drastic situations calls for drastic measures.

              I read the head-line of the attched piece and sigh.

              Maybe during the decision making process, PM Golding did not involve the human-rights lobbyists at the table...

              Still, Jamaica seems to have lots of special interest groups who just sits on the sidelines waiting to scuttle progressive decisions.

              Jamaica need the type of hard-nosed leadership who is willing to tell special interest know-it-all to "go jump into the sea!!"
              The only time TRUTH will hurt you...is if you ignore it long enough

              HL

              Comment

              Working...
              X