RBSC

Collapse

Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

JFF Western Confed football: A wise move to keep them apart

Collapse
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • JFF Western Confed football: A wise move to keep them apart



    A wise move to keep them apart <DIV class=KonaBody xVlvo="true">


    </DIV>


    file - The Catherine Hall Mini Stadium in Montego Bay.


    western bureau

    It is not difficult to understand the rationale behind the decision taken by the Jamaica Football Federation's (JFF) Western Confederation not to allow Captain's Bakery Western Super League contenders Granville FC and Montpelier to play each other on their respective home turfs, however, I find the whole situation distressing.

    Sports is supposed to be a vehicle to unite people but sadly, in this instance, because of the bitter/brutal rivalry between supporters of the two teams, the Everton Tomlinson-led confederation, has seemingly caved in to those fans, who have chosen to make indiscipline a way of life.

    Having personally witnessed a violent confrontation between supporters of the two teams, during a semi-final clash at the unfinished Catherine Hall Stadium last year, any sensible administrator would probably want to do every thing in his power to prevent a repeat of that ugly incident in which bottles and other missiles rained on the venue.

    While two members of the Hanover-based Montpelier team were slapped with bans in the aftermath of that incident, there might be some amount of lingering bitterness among some fans, especially those who sustained injury during the violent free-for-all which followed the premature ending of the game.


    no home turf games


    It is my understanding that the decision not to allow the teams to meet each other on their home turf this year was initiated by Montpelier, whose management believes that it would be courting trouble to play against the Montego Bay-based Granville anywhere in St. James.

    Granville's head honcho, Mrs. Tracy Reid has said that she is willing to give up her Sam Sharpe Teachers College home ground for another venue in St. James, but clearly resents the idea of being asked to play at the Elliston Wakeland Youth Centre, in Falmouth.

    According to Mrs. Reid, her team has moved on as far as last year's incident is concerned and holds no ill-will towards the Montpelier team. In fact, in expressing a readiness to play on Montpelier's home ground, she said she would prefer to see a return to normality between the teams instead of the effort to keep them apart.

    While I admire Mrs. Reid's sincerity, my concern surrounds those persons who follow the teams, labelling themselves fans. They do not contribute positively to the cause of the team, but are the first ones to throw a punch or start a fight at the slightest hint of provocation.

    While I can understand the additional expenses Granville will face, playing away in Falmouth, where they will be required to prepare the venue, put security in place and meet their transportation expenses, it might well prove less costly than to have a spectator being maimed or killed at one of the home venues.

    Before the teams are allowed to play each other on their home ground in the near future, I believe the teams should first begin to show that they are making an effort to exercise control over those fans, who are prone to uncivilised behaviour. It would also help if the leadership of the two clubs begin to lead by example.
    "Never doubt that a small group of thoughtful, committed citizens can change the world. Indeed, it is the only thing that ever has."

  • #2
    RE: JFF Western Confed football: A wise move to keep them apart

    Bored or dunce people should not be allowed to write in newspapers. There was a brawl, the Confed met and dealt with it, the game was replayed at a neutral venue without spectators ( I disagreed but hey I dont make the rules) the coaches from Montpelier were both Banned (yeah right), so what is the problem.

    This is not like Arnett and Tivoli where there was real war going on, this was a one-off incident that as far as one of the coaches involved says is over with and they have moved on.

    Why then woiuld the organisers then ask Granville to travel to Trelawny to play a 'home' game and Montpelier to drive from hanover through Montego Bay to play Granville in Trelawny?

    Who is paying for all that? seeing all the teams in the Confed are already cash strapped and can hardly afford to buy proper equipment for their players.

    Also how will playing games at neutral venueshelp normalise the situation between the teams...SIGH
    Solidarity is not a matter of well wishing, but is sharing the very same fate whether in victory or in death.
    Che Guevara.

    Comment


    • #3
      RE: JFF Western Confed football: A wise move to keep them apart

      There is a price to engage in boorish behaviour. Both organisation are ponying up! Maybe, there will be no repeat performance?
      "Never doubt that a small group of thoughtful, committed citizens can change the world. Indeed, it is the only thing that ever has."

      Comment


      • #4
        RE: JFF Western Confed football: A wise move to keep them apart

        Law of nature and law of man says you cant punish a man twice for the same crime, both teams faced the tribunal last year and both were punished already.

        Western Confederation needs to get their act together...
        Solidarity is not a matter of well wishing, but is sharing the very same fate whether in victory or in death.
        Che Guevara.

        Comment


        • #5
          RE: JFF Western Confed football: A wise move to keep them apart

          ...and, there is a saying that we should learn from past 'happenings'.

          The Western Confed leaders would have to make the decision on whether or not matches should be held at each team's home ground based on the leaders thinking on probability of a repeat of 'the war'.

          One question may have been;whether or not imposing a 'cooling out period' would lower the probability of new war duringfuture matches?

          Obviously a decision was taken to introduce such a 'cooling out period'.

          ....mmmm? There is another saying when thinking on actions that may have dire consequences - "It is better to err on the side of caution".
          "Never doubt that a small group of thoughtful, committed citizens can change the world. Indeed, it is the only thing that ever has."

          Comment


          • #6
            RE: JFF Western Confed football: A wise move to keep them apart

            Did you read where the coach of one team said they had forgotten about it and had moved on?

            Or that did not matter to you as you had to jump on your soap box and pontificate(N)
            Solidarity is not a matter of well wishing, but is sharing the very same fate whether in victory or in death.
            Che Guevara.

            Comment


            • #7
              RE: JFF Western Confed football: A wise move to keep them apart

              Sickko (1/28/2007)Did you read where the coach of one team said they had forgotten about it and had moved on?

              Or that did not matter to you as you had to jump on your soap box and pontificate(N)
              Yes!

              ...and, I took into consideration that that coach could have meant what he said...but, then again he could ahve been speaking with 'forked tongue'.

              ...but, let's say he meant it...does he also have the means to control and have all his fellow warriors toe the line?

              ...and, just suppose he could...should the WEstern Confed leaders read the minds of all and predict exactly - every little thing will be OK?

              A tad difficult? Right?

              ...as I said, there is a saying - "It is better better to err on the side of caution".

              I find no fault with the Western Confed's decision! Yup! --- I am OK with that decision!

              Even with such a decision 'war' could still occur...but, I think, it is less likely to occur. (Clap)(Clap)(Clap)
              "Never doubt that a small group of thoughtful, committed citizens can change the world. Indeed, it is the only thing that ever has."

              Comment

              Working...
              X