Tweet
Embarrassing WI
published: Saturday | June 9, 2007
England's Monty Panesar successfully appeals to umpire Aleem Dar (right) for the wicket of West Indies' Devon Smith during the second day of the third Test at Old Trafford, yesterday. - Reuters
MANCHESTER, England (Reuters):
THE WEST Indies suffered an embarrassing batting collapse to end their first innings on 229 and give England control of the third Test on the second day at Old Trafford yesterday.
The tourists were making steady progress in reply to England's 370 when they reached 216 for four, only to lose their last six wickets for 13 runs in 44 balls. Their innings lasted just 52.4 overs.
Spinner Monty Panesar took four wickets for 50 runs and seamer Ryan Sidebottom three for 48 to give England a healthy first innings lead of 141.
England reached 34 for one before the close of play after opener Andrew Strauss's barren spell continued when he was lbw to pace bowler Fidel Edwards without scoring. He is without a 50 in his past 15 Test innings.
Alastair Cook was 12 not out, though appeared to have survived a good caught behind appeal off Corey Collymore, and captain Michael Vaughan was on 10.
"It was very disappointing, obviously," West Indies coach David Moore said.
"I thought that (Runako) Morton, (Shivnarine) Chanderpaul and (Devon) Smith had worked pretty hard and (Dwayne) Bravo chipped in to get us into a good position.
"I thought there were some poor shots played," he added. "It led to a situation where we went from being in a very good position at tea time to a very poor position and bowling again in the same day.
"We wanted to give our bowlers a rest but we didn't bat well enough to do that."
Bright start
England started the day brightly, adding 74 to their overnight total as Ian Bell was out for 97.
West Indies then lost stand-in captain Daren Ganga lbw to Steve Harmison in the three overs possible before lunch.
Harmison struggled with his line all day and though he occasionally showed evidence of the form which brought him 11 wickets on the ground against Pakistan last year, he was largely disappointing and erratic, as was Liam Plunkett.
Harmison's other wicket, to dismiss Runako Morton (35), was a frustrating reminder of his capabilities, as the batsman edged a lifter to Strauss at first slip.
West Indies slumped to 157 for four when Devon Smith fell to Panesar seven balls after tea to give the left-arm spinner his 50th Test victim.
The six-wicket burst to follow would have dented West Indies' morale after what had been a promising comeback match following their record defeat in the second Test at Headingley.
Dwayne Bravo edged Side-bottom to the wicketkeeper for 24, Denesh Ramdin was caught from a mistimed pull shot at square leg, also off Sidebottom. Then Panesar had Darren Sammy and Jerome Taylor caught close in.
Top scorer Shivnarine Chander-paul joined the procession and his lone resistance of 50 off 78 balls was ended when he drove Sidebottom to cover. Panesar wrapped up the innings by having Corey Collymore caught at slip.
published: Saturday | June 9, 2007
England's Monty Panesar successfully appeals to umpire Aleem Dar (right) for the wicket of West Indies' Devon Smith during the second day of the third Test at Old Trafford, yesterday. - Reuters
MANCHESTER, England (Reuters):
THE WEST Indies suffered an embarrassing batting collapse to end their first innings on 229 and give England control of the third Test on the second day at Old Trafford yesterday.
The tourists were making steady progress in reply to England's 370 when they reached 216 for four, only to lose their last six wickets for 13 runs in 44 balls. Their innings lasted just 52.4 overs.
Spinner Monty Panesar took four wickets for 50 runs and seamer Ryan Sidebottom three for 48 to give England a healthy first innings lead of 141.
England reached 34 for one before the close of play after opener Andrew Strauss's barren spell continued when he was lbw to pace bowler Fidel Edwards without scoring. He is without a 50 in his past 15 Test innings.
Alastair Cook was 12 not out, though appeared to have survived a good caught behind appeal off Corey Collymore, and captain Michael Vaughan was on 10.
"It was very disappointing, obviously," West Indies coach David Moore said.
"I thought that (Runako) Morton, (Shivnarine) Chanderpaul and (Devon) Smith had worked pretty hard and (Dwayne) Bravo chipped in to get us into a good position.
"I thought there were some poor shots played," he added. "It led to a situation where we went from being in a very good position at tea time to a very poor position and bowling again in the same day.
"We wanted to give our bowlers a rest but we didn't bat well enough to do that."
Bright start
England started the day brightly, adding 74 to their overnight total as Ian Bell was out for 97.
West Indies then lost stand-in captain Daren Ganga lbw to Steve Harmison in the three overs possible before lunch.
Harmison struggled with his line all day and though he occasionally showed evidence of the form which brought him 11 wickets on the ground against Pakistan last year, he was largely disappointing and erratic, as was Liam Plunkett.
Harmison's other wicket, to dismiss Runako Morton (35), was a frustrating reminder of his capabilities, as the batsman edged a lifter to Strauss at first slip.
West Indies slumped to 157 for four when Devon Smith fell to Panesar seven balls after tea to give the left-arm spinner his 50th Test victim.
The six-wicket burst to follow would have dented West Indies' morale after what had been a promising comeback match following their record defeat in the second Test at Headingley.
Dwayne Bravo edged Side-bottom to the wicketkeeper for 24, Denesh Ramdin was caught from a mistimed pull shot at square leg, also off Sidebottom. Then Panesar had Darren Sammy and Jerome Taylor caught close in.
Top scorer Shivnarine Chander-paul joined the procession and his lone resistance of 50 off 78 balls was ended when he drove Sidebottom to cover. Panesar wrapped up the innings by having Corey Collymore caught at slip.
Comment