Simpson dope case: Attorney questions doctor's qualifications
Wednesday, February 05, 2014 | 5:00 PM
Print this page Email A Friend!
Dr. Paul Wright
KINGSTON, Jamaica – Sprinter Sherone Simpson's defence attorney Kwame Gordon Wednesday tore into Jamaica anti-Doping Commission (JADCO) witness Dr Paul Wright about his qualification to speak authoritatively on supplements in the human body.
Dr Wright, who has over the 35 years experience in the doping cases, had previously advised athletes not to take supplements but to instead consult an accredited sports dietician, a registered nutritionist with expertise in sports nutrition or a sports and exercise-medicine doctor. “Athletes generally do not need to take supplements,” Dr Wright instructed.
But Gordon while cross-examination of Dr Wright, Wednesday questioned whether or not he had any scientific research that says follow a dietician’s plan instead of taking supplements.
“No sir that’s common sense,” replied Dr Wright.
“In the profession that you practise are your opinions based on common sense or research"? Gordon continued.
“Research, experience and common sense,” said Dr Wright.
Then Gordon questioned Dr Wright’s qualifications noting that he failed three times to pass the medical examination in Jamaica.
“Have you received any certification that gives you the authority to speak on how a supplement works in a human body"? Gordon asked. “Yes,” replied Dr Wright.
He was then shown a copy of his qualifications and asked to show the medical training that he received that allowed him to speak authoritatively on supplements in a human body.
Gordon then bombarded Dr Wright with questions about JADCO educational programme as being unacceptable, not even having a website to inform athletes.
Dr Wright paused, then laughed, asked for forgiveness saying the last time he answered a question like that he got in serious trouble.
“Is there a fifth amendment in this country,” joked Dr Wright. “Council that’s a very embarrassing question for me on a personal note.”
“I don’t embarrass you. I won’t press you further than that, I think your response speaks volumes,” said Gordon.
By Howard Walker
ADVERTISEMENT
Wednesday, February 05, 2014 | 5:00 PM
Print this page Email A Friend!
Dr. Paul Wright
KINGSTON, Jamaica – Sprinter Sherone Simpson's defence attorney Kwame Gordon Wednesday tore into Jamaica anti-Doping Commission (JADCO) witness Dr Paul Wright about his qualification to speak authoritatively on supplements in the human body.
Dr Wright, who has over the 35 years experience in the doping cases, had previously advised athletes not to take supplements but to instead consult an accredited sports dietician, a registered nutritionist with expertise in sports nutrition or a sports and exercise-medicine doctor. “Athletes generally do not need to take supplements,” Dr Wright instructed.
But Gordon while cross-examination of Dr Wright, Wednesday questioned whether or not he had any scientific research that says follow a dietician’s plan instead of taking supplements.
“No sir that’s common sense,” replied Dr Wright.
“In the profession that you practise are your opinions based on common sense or research"? Gordon continued.
“Research, experience and common sense,” said Dr Wright.
Then Gordon questioned Dr Wright’s qualifications noting that he failed three times to pass the medical examination in Jamaica.
“Have you received any certification that gives you the authority to speak on how a supplement works in a human body"? Gordon asked. “Yes,” replied Dr Wright.
He was then shown a copy of his qualifications and asked to show the medical training that he received that allowed him to speak authoritatively on supplements in a human body.
Gordon then bombarded Dr Wright with questions about JADCO educational programme as being unacceptable, not even having a website to inform athletes.
Dr Wright paused, then laughed, asked for forgiveness saying the last time he answered a question like that he got in serious trouble.
“Is there a fifth amendment in this country,” joked Dr Wright. “Council that’s a very embarrassing question for me on a personal note.”
“I don’t embarrass you. I won’t press you further than that, I think your response speaks volumes,” said Gordon.
By Howard Walker
ADVERTISEMENT
Comment