RBSC

Collapse

Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

JAAA is athletics' deadbeat dad

Collapse
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • JAAA is athletics' deadbeat dad

    JAAA is athletics' deadbeat dad

    Published: Friday | August 24, 2012



    Long-distance runners like Semoya Campbell of Spalding High are unlikely to thrive globally if the JAAA doesn't source professional help, says Orville Higgins. - FILE




    Orville Higgins





    By Orville Higgins

    It's now confirmed, if anyone had any doubts, that Jamaica is the sprint capital of the world.


    Maybe I'm just greedy, or maybe it's just part of human nature to hanker for what you don't have, but I feel it's now time we seriously look at doing well in the longer distances and put a plan in place so that, as early as the next Olympics in Brazil, we should be more competitive in the 400m and the 800m, at least. This is something that the Jamaica Athletics Administrative Association (JAAA) can take on as a real project.

    The JAAA can take no real credit for what we have done on the global stage. I am aware that, from time to time, the organisation may help with individual athletes or particular school programmes, but, as a rule, Jamaica is dominant in the sprints without the parent body of track and field being 'responsible' for our success.

    Champs is the arena where most of Jamaica's future athletic stars get their feet wet in high-quality performances, and learning how to handle pressure. It's the single biggest reason behind Jamaica's success in the sprints globally.

    Champs is, however, organised by ISSA, not the JAAA, and so the latter, by and large, is an organisation that has an international profile because of the success of our sprinters, despite doing very little to earn that status.

    TIME TO EARN ITS STRIPES
    The time has come for the JAAA to earn its stripes. The local governing body for track and field must now see itself as an entity that not only presides over successful athletes, but as an organisation that helps to create them.

    The yawning gap between our performance in the sprints and our exploits elsewhere is something that the JAAA should now see as a concern. It must be proactive at putting plans and systems in place to remedy that imbalance. In other words, the JAAA can no longer sit by and leave the high schools and their coaches, as well as local professional clubs, to plot the way forward for Jamaica's track and field programme.

    This isn't done in any other sport. In football, cricket, volleyball and netball, for example, it is the presidents of those associations, together with their executives, that determine the direction of their sport.
    In these sports, it is the national association that has to come up with plans and programmes to ensure that the sport is thriving at the lower levels, while always ensuring that the national team is as strong as it should be.

    Track and field is different. The sport is driven by different factors elsewhere, and the JAAA is almost like the absentee father who 'live a foreign', visits home sporadically, does very little to assist his child financially, does very little 'fathering', and then beams with pride at his child's high-school or university graduation. That's not good enough.
    The JAAA must be more responsible and proactive in plotting the direction in track and field.

    I would advise that organisation to come up with a plan to improve other disciplines in the sport outside of sprinting. This could mean anything from importing specialist coaches in the other events, to sending away our top athletes in the other disciplines to get special attention overseas. This must be done as a rule, annually, and not something that is pursued in a sporadic or ad hoc fashion.

    Another thing the JAAA could do is create bigger incentive packages for those who do well outside of the sprints. How about offering a substantial monetary reward for high-school students and their coaches who come close to world standards in, say, the 800m or the 1500m. The reason we don't do well in those events is that, in Jamaica, glamour doesn't surround those disciplines. Therefore, neither coaches nor athletes take the longer distances as seriously as we should.

    Rather than just bemoaning that fact, we ought to do something about it so that our talented high-school athletes can see genuine benefits in competing outside the sprints. If we don't do that, we will be perennially celebrating our sprinters at the Olympics, while continuing to wonder about stillborn opportunities elsewhere.

    Over to you, JAAA.

    Sportscaster Orville Higgins is the 2011 winner of the Hugh Crosskill/Raymond Sharpe Award for Sports Reporting. Email feedback to columns@gleanerjm.com.








    http://jamaica-gleaner.com/gleaner/2...cleisure3.html
    "Never doubt that a small group of thoughtful, committed citizens can change the world. Indeed, it is the only thing that ever has."

  • #2
    Thanks For Posting This!

    Thanks for posting this newspaper commentary, Karl.

    I would be remiss if I didn’t publicly commend the writer, Orville Higgins, for this timely and certainly relevant look at the apparent paradox that the Jamaica track and field scenario/success is. And, like all good critical commentaries, Mr. Higgins doesn’t merely criticize the JAAA, but he also includes practical recommendations for moving forward.

    The metaphor used in the headline (and turned into a simile later in the article) sums up the situation in a brutally accurate way! In fact, just a few weeks ago I posted an old news report on the 2004 JAAA elections with my personal additions, so the Massive on this forum should know my stance by now. No matter how much one wants to spin it, Mr. Higgins is absolutely correct when he writes that “the JAAA can take no real credit for what we have done on the global stage.”

    This is not only a very good, concise commentary on a perplexing situation, but it is, unfortunately, as Keith Noel pointed out in his commentary, “London Glory - ‘Buk Up?’ ” (The Daily Gleaner, Thursday, August 16, 2012), the story of the Caribbean!

    In Jamaica’s case, this lack of central planning and a national program has to stop now if we are to move beyond what we have already achieved, success in the sprints ALONE (along with Hansle Parchment in the 110-meter hurdles).

    Comment


    • #3
      Aaaah...Historian?

      ...but to return to Orville's comments:
      i) I made the same comment in 2000 (I think) when pointing to our football and used the actions of the then JAAA as reference in what could and should be done by the football authorities.

      ii) ...and on addressing T&F on one of the web sites - The Caribbean T&F Forum or our ReggaeBoyz.com - I made mention of exactly the same comments as Orville.

      ...at first glance it would appear that I spoke out of 'two sides of my month'.

      First, we should recognise that the work of the schools on youth development through sports and the development of age-group sport in various discipline has been a long process. Those efforts by the schools have been ongoing long before the JAAA and the JFF came into being.

      Second, the work of the teachers in these areas cannot be replicated or replaced (forget the nonsense suggestion by some of by-passing or ignoring same).

      The truth is as it pertains to T&F the JAAA has been from at least when Freddie Green was its president provided the schools and more importantly the teachers colleges with expert international guidance on coaching, organisation of meets, etc.

      Certainly I can remember being privy at Mico College in the 1960s to international track officials visiting and being presenters at JAAA seminars.

      The idea behind educating teachers, student-teachers, coaches, administrators, etc. was improved competence in the various technical areas and the spread and sharing of such across the island (as Mico stalwart R.A. Shirley - father of our UWI-Mona current president - of blessed memory used to say "take it through-out the country...into every nook and cranny").

      I called out the JFF and the JAAA, the former for the then 'talk' in the corridors of power of subjugating the ISSA and the schools to its 'power' (damn misguided fools!!!) and the former for haphazard and puny 'start-stop' efforts at working with the schools and colleges to foster more rapid transfer of knowledge and thus even 'greater results'. - Incidentally, I (used to) think the reluctance to fully work with the colleges and schools stemed from a perceived reluctance by the leaders of those institutions to share 'glory' on any real or perceived achievements??? ...a selfishness??? ...a desire to 'beat one's chest'??? ...an mogle???

      As Orville suggests the national bodies can and must contribute more to further improve the work in the schools and secondly, complement the work done by the schools.

      Glad you liked the post.
      'Nice' article - Well done, Orville.
      "Never doubt that a small group of thoughtful, committed citizens can change the world. Indeed, it is the only thing that ever has."

      Comment


      • #4
        Re: JAAA 1960s Initiatives

        Originally posted by Karl View Post
        The truth is as it pertains to T&F the JAAA has been from at least when Freddie Green was its president provided the schools and more importantly the teachers colleges with expert international guidance on coaching, organisation of meets, etc.

        Certainly I can remember being privy at Mico College in the 1960s to international track officials visiting and being presenters at JAAA seminars.

        The idea behind educating teachers, student-teachers, coaches, administrators, etc. was improved competence in the various technical areas and the spread and sharing of such across the island (as Mico stalwart R.A. Shirley - father of our UWI-Mona current president - of blessed memory used to say "take it through-out the country...into every nook and cranny").
        Well, all I can say/ask is why has it taken so long to see the international fruits of these 1960s labors by the JAAA? And while I cannot see it, is there a connection between these efforts on the one hand and, on the other, the successes of athletes like Veronica Campbell and Usain Bolt at the junior level starting in the late 1990s? Were the coaches at Vere Tech and William Knibb, etc. a successful product of these 1960s initiatives?

        Until the 2006 Commonwealth Games, and even more specifically until the emergence of MVP and afterwards Racers clubs in the 21st century, we were certainly not having a local club-influenced dominating presence in the sprints at major senior meets in the way we are doing now!

        For heaven’s sake, Karl, we’re talking about some 40-plus years since the JAAA efforts, during which if it were not for the US NCAA system, we would not even be discussing Jamaican success in the pre-2008 Olympic Games and the pre-2009 IAAF World Championships!!

        In other words, what was the level of success, if any, of these JAAA initiatives?

        I suspect that I’m missing something in my comments, but I’m not sure what it is!!

        Comment


        • #5
          Everybody wants to claim success for the efforts of Mills/Franno now. Quite comical.

          Comment


          • #6
            while comical, it is also typical. remember rev archer and jodi ann foster?

            Infidelity does not consist in believing, or in disbelieving; it consists in professing to believe what he does not believe. Thomas Paine

            Comment


            • #7
              Originally posted by Historian View Post
              Well, all I can say/ask is why has it taken so long to see the international fruits of these 1960s labors by the JAAA? And while I cannot see it, is there a connection between these efforts on the one hand and, on the other, the successes of athletes like Veronica Campbell and Usain Bolt at the junior level starting in the late 1990s? Were the coaches at Vere Tech and William Knibb, etc. a successful product of these 1960s initiatives?

              Until the 2006 Commonwealth Games, and even more specifically until the emergence of MVP and afterwards Racers clubs in the 21st century, we were certainly not having a local club-influenced dominating presence in the sprints at major senior meets in the way we are doing now!

              For heaven’s sake, Karl, we’re talking about some 40-plus years since the JAAA efforts, during which if it were not for the US NCAA system, we would not even be discussing Jamaican success in the pre-2008 Olympic Games and the pre-2009 IAAF World Championships!!

              In other words, what was the level of success, if any, of these JAAA initiatives?

              I suspect that I’m missing something in my comments, but I’m not sure what it is!!

              Re: For Heaven's sake...
              It is simple - Schools (Primary then called Elementary Schools -- 'racing' & other running games. One of the early ones was 2 teams with a 'home base' whenon kids ran to touch opponents taking prisoners...until a team won by capturing all the runners on the other side) -> Local College System (in the early days most sports masters were local college trained teachers) + JAAAs (came in late...as Orville article states JAAAs - still 'late' = not living up to full potential on 'moving the process onwards'.

              ...but let me ask as I am not up-to-date on what is the current situation; is the JAAAs still supplying technical expertise to local coaches? ...or is it only the local colleges inclusive of GC Foster that is providing avenue for improved coaching experiences?

              Aside: Our local college trained coaches were so respected that US colleges were recruiting from that group from at least 20+ years past. One such I remember is Wally, Jackie Walters' brother, who was recruited from Vere Technical.

              ...a recent recruit to a US college was the Mico then GC Foster man - St Jago High coach "KC" Graham. Incidentally - "KC" is also a JFRA JFF certified football referee. He was a ref long before taking up coaching duties - He became a ref via JFRA/JFF/Mico course. Last I heard he was back at Mico as Director of Sports ...could/should be viewed as the process continuing.

              Surely an athlete or other student who learnt or passed through our current system ('helping out with and being taught/learning/being an apprentice/apprenticeship...) who then goes to a college outside of the island and returns to share knowledge gained/infuses new insights...merely is part of the 'perpetual renewal' process? ...a link in the (continuation) chain?
              Last edited by Karl; August 29, 2012, 06:58 PM.
              "Never doubt that a small group of thoughtful, committed citizens can change the world. Indeed, it is the only thing that ever has."

              Comment


              • #8
                Originally posted by Willi View Post
                Everybody wants to claim success for the efforts of Mills/Franno now. Quite comical.
                Never ever heard of anyone claiming Mills or Franno successes being his/her own? A who dem be?
                "Never doubt that a small group of thoughtful, committed citizens can change the world. Indeed, it is the only thing that ever has."

                Comment


                • #9
                  Karl - A Gold Medalist Question

                  The following senior athletes won GOLD medals for Jamaica in global events between 2008 and now (individual events and relays).

                  1. Where was each athlete trained, and what direct input did the JAAA have?
                  2. Did any of the coaches you mentioned directly and indirectly in your post coach them during their senior years?

                  Jamaican Gold Medalists: 2008-2012

                  Shelly-Ann Fraser-Pryce
                  Veronica Campbell-Brown
                  Melaine Walker
                  Brigitte Foster-Hylton
                  Kerron Stewart
                  Sherone Simpson
                  Simone Facey
                  Aleen Bailey

                  Usain Bolt
                  Yohan Blake
                  Asafa Powell
                  Nesta Carter
                  Michael Frater
                  Steve Mullings


                  Comment


                  • #10
                    Originally posted by Historian View Post
                    The following senior athletes won GOLD medals for Jamaica in global events between 2008 and now (individual events and relays).

                    1. Where was each athlete trained, and what direct input did the JAAA have?
                    2. Did any of the coaches you mentioned directly and indirectly in your post coach them during their senior years?

                    Jamaican Gold Medalists: 2008-2012

                    Shelly-Ann Fraser-Pryce
                    Veronica Campbell-Brown
                    Melaine Walker
                    Brigitte Foster-Hylton
                    Kerron Stewart
                    Sherone Simpson
                    Simone Facey
                    Aleen Bailey

                    Usain Bolt
                    Yohan Blake
                    Asafa Powell
                    Nesta Carter
                    Michael Frater
                    Steve Mullings


                    I will answer you thus: You have to have had 'early years' before being discovered...and before becoming TOP of the WORLD!

                    I took a quick look at your list and I think all went to 'school' in JA, at least in those 'early years'!

                    Historian: It is too easy to throw out the formative years and then claim all learnt was in later life. It is just not possible to 'born big suh'!

                    All I have said and am saying: The JAAAs have been providing technical assistance/input from at least 20 years past!
                    "Never doubt that a small group of thoughtful, committed citizens can change the world. Indeed, it is the only thing that ever has."

                    Comment


                    • #11
                      Pay attention then. LoL

                      Comment

                      Working...
                      X